 |
 |
 |
 |
Besides
the difficulties of a "structural order", which always weigh on the
issue of education, our time offers another, in order
"conjunctural", typical of an era of transition, in which all the
transformations that affect the culture and custom create a sense of
rootlessness that eventually unite young people and adults. Simply
putting, we could say that we are experiencing a reversal in the way of
living time, and then the sense of distance and perspective. On the one
season where you felt the need to get out of a small world to build a
great shared history, we are entering into a season where every distant
horizon has become too close and we feel the opposite need to cling to
this time, leaving us attract by its seductions and its promises.
Asymmetrical reciprocity
In this way a fundamental factor log in crisis in the
education, based on a form of asymmetrical reciprocity. The
Reciprocity indicates the "bilateral nature" and not the unique
relationship that can not be "one way", as in authoritarian perspective.
The asymmetry indicates the difference of the positions (and thus
roles), which implies a difference of functional (not ontological)
order. The human experience of living a plot of involuntary and
voluntary relationships, asymmetrical and symmetrical, which go far
beyond any contractual paradigm. We are not only made of symmetrical and
marketable contacts, the relationship dimensions that shapes our
identity comes from a completely different network links. We did not
choose our parents on the same way and at the same time that they have
chosen us; we didn’t choose our local or national level community, nor
the coordinates of historical, geographical and cultural factors that
shape the space of our existence; we haven’t chosen our sex, we did not
choose to be born.
This gives rise to the difference of the educational
relationship, which consists of continuing to give life in another way:
for in the generation, which extends beyond the biological sphere,
springs the duty to accompany and the right to be accompanied. In a
pervasive culture besieged by the mercantilist model of exchange, based
on a total contractual arrangements, it is particularly difficult to
accept a form of relationship that is not, however, the result of a
revocable and conventional act between peer. Not surprisingly, the
educational relationship, especially at school level, now tends to be
assimilated to that, typically economic, that exists between supplier
and customer, between buyers and sellers of goods.
In fact, my life will not turn on and off as the list
of Facebook friends. The dream of being able to "start from
scratch", which projects an ancient and dangerous delirium of
omnipotence, now comes in a new form, which does not come up to a plan
of collective emancipation and mortgage of the future, as was in great
modern utopias; it appears more like a blind greed of this present
(Life is now!), besieged economicistic ideology of flexibility, the
media pressure of consumerism, from the flattery of the real digital
siege around us.
Anesthesia relational
The myth of autonomy, which in modern culture fed
uncompromising policy planning, in the post-modern era is presented in
the research, all private, of a liberation from the burden of history:
my life can always be reborn in the game "variable geometry" of
voluntary relations.
Just like in a video game: when you lose a
game you can reset the system and start over. The time of life is less
and less perceived as part of an irreversible and shared flow, to which
is traditionally given the name of history, and it is increasingly
experienced as a chaotic and incoherent combination of fragments of
self- reference. It is not difficult to read in this drift, in which
even love becomes a liquid, as Bauman reminds us, the attempt of the
dissolution of all ties, "Love is a net threw into eternity, the desire
is a stratagem to save himself the task of weaving the web".
In this kind of "relational anesthesia" the
individual gives up to clot ties in stable and lasting relationships,
satisfying to consumers in the form of fleeting and fickle contacts:
"When you skate on thin ice your salvation is to be fast " (Ralph Waldo
Emerson).
The step from the flexibility to
work with the flexibility in the affections is short: the loss of roots
is compensated by the
promise not to suffer. Typing in a systematic way in the deep veins
of human relations solvents rather than just glue, the individual who
renounces to bind receives in exchange a powerful anesthetic. Who does
not love does not suffer, the loss of the pain is - according to this
way of thinking- such as the only possible happiness.
Adults too
young?
At this point, the reader might object that this
analysis does not help us to differentiate the adult world from young
people. In fact, it's just the point: it is reducing that difference,
without which the relationship does not become a real education to
accompany the growth. To educate is a voice of the verb to grow, and
today, behind the glittering bustle of our lives on the run, at a time
when everything changes swirling, everything finally seems to turn up
empty itself.
The change is real and not illusory when it fits into
a story, it introduces a gap between a before and an after in the
journey of life, replacing to the repetitive let live the creative
novelty of living. A novelty that does not assert, however, through a
reset of the past, unrealistic and impossible, but as a response to a
vocation to cultivate, enrich, release, promote, in a focused and
progressive way.
In this sense, the educator must take responsibility
for a dynamic synthesis between the nature and the culture, and the
culture is precisely a form of the "spiritual cultivation "of the
nature, which means they who must know how to respect and to
encourage, to welcome and to orient the sense of vocation and timing of
growth. The " added value " compared to the purely natural level is the
ability to "give back" to the world -in a perfectible and uninterrupted
form- more than we received. The body and the emotions, the work and the
free time, the inner life and the relationships, the transcendence and
the history: the entry into adulthood is marked by the ability to not be
divided between these (and other) dimensions of life, but to unify them
in a neat summary in the way of their maturing.
The true adult is someone who reaches a relative
stabilization of their life orientation: the search for meaning is not
dissipated, scattering in all directions, but it puts deep roots that
identify and shape a state of life. Not everything is done -it's true-
in the sign of authenticity, you can also give up the routine,
the interested calculation involved in unscrupulous cynicism.
However it is undeniable that a true teacher is one
who knows "answer" for one's vocation: vocation and responsibility is
the indispensable combination of the adulthood condition. A combination
now endangered by a pathetic and irresponsible youthfulness, which many
parents and teachers give up being themselves, deceiving to hide their
weak identity with a mask of jovial demagoguery.
Period of
short-sighted
The life of faith is affected by this horizons’
shortening, when it becomes in a comforting mixture, made of refined
spiritual chills, in which reward an existence hungry for thrilling
emotions. The bad, the limit, the suffering and the death are dimensions
that we tend to hide more and more to our boys.
Let's face it: we have not even words to announce the
last things, to nourish the hope of new heavens and new earth. Yet it is
precisely in the light of eternity that the time becomes more valuable,
and only the infinite truly expands the horizon of the finite. Our faith
is genuine, if he can testify that true salvation is to close our eyes
to our vulnerability, but in opening to the resurrection.
This openness is credible, and not presented as an
evasion of responsibility before the history, when it can transmit to
the youngest the infection of the great ideals, great goals, great
horizons. That's where the issue of education meets the challenge more
difficult and decisive: in its ability to be "carriers" of a contagion
of infinity.
In an era of short-sighted, in which politics,
culture and even the school seem content simply to decorate the present
and the promises of adults should be up to the expectations of the
young, which shake and call into question our myopia and our
accommodating and painless conformism. It's appropriate to say with
Kierkegaard: "What needs our time is eternity."
Luigi Alici
Docente all'Università di Macerata
Via
G. Mazzini 11
63024 Grottazzolina (Fermo)
1. Z. BAUMAN, Amore liquido, Laterza, Roma-Bari 2003, 16.
2. I’ve dwelt on this paradox in the book
Amare e legarsi. Il paradosso della
reciprocità, Meudon, Portogruaro 2010.
 |